Metals 1 SPV update
Hi everyone,
After seven weeks of diligence, we’ve decided not to move forward with the Metals I SPV, the rare earth metals deal we were working on with our friends at Earth Rarest.
Why we passed on the deal
Information gaps. Several key diligence questions went unanswered, including buyback history (especially through rhodium’s recent drawdown), custody and ownership arrangements, and who the underlying suppliers are. We needed those answers before we felt comfortable finalizing the deal.
Fees. This was the biggest issue. Rare earths are hard to source, and some intermediaries are to be expected, sure. But there’s a point where too many hands are in the pie, and this deal was past it. Four separate layers sat between the metal and you. Here’s what that added up to:
a 10% purchase premium on the way in
storage of 0.24% per month (nearly 3% a year), well above the provider’s advertised rate
a roughly 10% discount when the metal is sold back at exit
On our modeling, if the basket doubled over five years, you’d have ended up with about 1.33x, or roughly 5.9% a year. We pushed hard for better terms and didn’t get a counter offer. The fees ultimately made the deal untenable/not worth pursuing.
This isn’t the outcome we were hoping for, but it’s the right call for our community.
If you’re still interested in rare earths
Rare earths/strategic metals can still be a great alternative investment. If you’ve already expressed interest, it’s been registered. The Earth Rarest team is still working on sourcing more materials at better prices.
If you’d like to pursue a rare earths allocation on your own terms, you can reach Alon directly — comment below or send @Al R a direct message.
What’s next
This deal is ending, but we’re launching something very special in the wake of our Japan trip.
You’ll start hearing about it this Sunday. It’s hands down one of the most exciting things we’ve done all year. More to come.
In the meantime, thank you for your patience and understanding.
— Stefan, Wyatt, Alon & team.